Rose de Caroline vs Rose Malaki

People who smelled both call them a weak match, but people are split. Rose Malaki is sweeter, and Rose de Caroline is longer lasting.

How alike are they?

People are split

The meter shows how close people who smelled both say they are.

Based on a few votes

Where they differ

  • Rose Malaki is sweeter.
  • Rose de Caroline is longer lasting.
  • Rose Malaki leans more masculine.
Based on many votes

How they wear

Longevity
Long lastingBased on many votes
Moderate longevityBased on many votes
Projection
Moderate projectionStronger projection than 55% of fragrancesBased on many votes
Moderate projectionBased on many votes
Gender lean
Unisex, leans feminineBased on many votes
UnisexBased on many votes

What they're made of

Rose de Caroline

Main accords
  • Floral
  • Powdery
  • Rose
  • Spicy
  • Oriental
  • Citrus

Rose Malaki

Main accords
  • Woody
  • Floral
  • Oriental
  • Spicy
  • Sweet
Top notes

Which one is for you?

Pick Rose de Caroline if…

  • you want one that is less sweet
  • you want one that is longer lasting
  • you want one that leans more feminine

Pick Rose Malaki if…

  • you want one that is sweeter
  • you want one that is shorter lasting
  • you want one that leans more masculine