Carlisle vs Lost Americana
People who smelled both call them a weak match. Carlisle is sweeter, and Carlisle is longer lasting.
- Parfums de Marly · 2015Carlisle
- Dossier · 2025Lost Americana
How alike are they?
The meter shows how close people who smelled both say they are.
Based on a few votesWhere they differ
- Carlisle is sweeter.
- Carlisle is longer lasting.
- Carlisle leans more masculine.
How they wear
Longevity
Very long lastingLonger lasting than 90% of fragrancesBased on lots of votes
Long lastingLonger lasting than 75% of fragrancesBased on many votes
Projection
Strong projectionStronger projection than 85% of fragrancesBased on lots of votes
Strong projectionStronger projection than 70% of fragrancesBased on many votes
Gender lean
Leans masculineBased on lots of votes
Unisex, leans masculineBased on many votes
What they're made of
Carlisle
Main accords
- Patchouli
- Sweet
- Vanilla
- Amber
- Balsamic
- Fresh spicy
Top notes
- green apple
- nutmeg
- saffron
Heart notes
- davana
- osmanthus
- rose
- tonka bean
Base notes
- opoponax
- patchouli
- vanilla
- sandalwood
Lost Americana
Main accords
- Smoky
- Sweet
- Woody
- Amber
- Warm spicy
- Balsamic
Top notes
Heart notes
- cinnamon
- myrrh
- nutmeg
Which one is for you?
Pick Carlisle if…
- you want one that is sweeter
- you want one that is longer lasting
- you want one that leans more masculine
Pick Lost Americana if…
- you want one that is less sweet
- you want one that is shorter lasting
- you want one that leans more feminine