Good Girl vs She s a Goodie
People who smelled both call them a fair match, and most agree. Good Girl is sweeter, and Good Girl is longer lasting.
- Carolina HerreraGood Girl
- Fine'ry · 2024She s a Goodie
How alike are they?
Most agree
The meter shows how close people who smelled both say they are.
Based on a few votesWhere they differ
- Good Girl is sweeter.
- Good Girl is longer lasting.
- Good Girl projects more strongly.
How they wear
Longevity
Long lastingBased on lots of votes
Short lastingBased on a few votes
Projection
Moderate projectionBased on lots of votes
Soft projectionBased on a few votes
Gender lean
Leans feminineBased on lots of votes
Leans feminineBased on a few votes
What they're made of
Good Girl
Main accords
- Sweet
- Vanilla
- Warm spicy
- White floral
- Almond
- Amber
Heart notes
Base notes
- amber
- cacao
- cashmere wood
- cedar
- cinnamon
- musk
- patchouli
- praline
- sandalwood
- tonka bean
- vanilla
She s a Goodie
Main accords
- White floral
- Tuberose
- Animalic
- Fruity
- Green
- Lactonic
Top notes
- plum
Heart notes
- gardenia
Base notes
- tuberose
Which one is for you?
Pick Good Girl if…
- you want one that is sweeter
- you want one that is longer lasting
- you want one that projects more strongly
Pick She s a Goodie if…
- you want one that is less sweet
- you want one that is shorter lasting
- you want one that projects more softly