Cucumber MelonSecret Wish
Cucumber Melon vs Secret Wish
People who smelled both call them a weak match. Secret Wish is sweeter, and Cucumber Melon leans more masculine.
- Bath & Body WorksCucumber Melon
- Anna Sui · 2005Secret Wish
How alike are they?
The meter shows how close people who smelled both say they are.
Based on a few votesWhere they differ
- Secret Wish is sweeter.
- Cucumber Melon leans more masculine.
How they wear
Longevity
Short lastingBased on many votes
Short lastingBased on many votes
Projection
Soft projectionBased on many votes
Soft projectionBased on many votes
Gender lean
Unisex, leans feminineBased on a few votes
Leans feminineBased on many votes
What they're made of
Which one is for you?
Pick Cucumber Melon if…
- you want one that is less sweet
- you want one that leans more masculine
Pick Secret Wish if…
- you want one that is sweeter
- you want one that leans more feminine